Friends of Belle Isle Aquarium
Group puts pressure on to
The City Council will vote
Wednesday whether to delay closure for a year.
By Judy Lin / The Detroit News
Max Ortiz / The Detroit News
Tasia Lynch of
Livonia with children John, 11, Fia, 8, and niece Mira Dbouk, 9, walk
out of Belle Isle Aquarium, which the city has proposed closing in March
to fill a budget hole.
Detroit City Councilwoman JoAnn Watson has drafted a resolution granting
community and philanthropic groups one year to identify other sources of
funding and the establishment of an endowment. City Council could vote
as early as Wednesday.
Friends of Belle Isle Aquarium has requested a meeting with the mayor.
Amid budget crisis, the aquarium on Belle Isle deserves chance to
Belle Isle's beauty shines through its blemishes
Aquarium has more to offer than a few fatherless fish
Strait of Detroit shaped our fate
Belle Isle, the Beloved
The orchids that saved the Belle Isle Conservatory
Belle Isle's retired ships
Detroit's fountain of mirth
More on Education
# Future journalists are wired into information - 02/22/05
# Taking away gays' rights gets personal - 02/21/05
# Commerce Township Bucks Trend to Build New Library - 02/17/05
More on Finances
# Lottery winners lose out - 02/22/05
# Bush won't win battle of budget bulge - 02/21/05
# Trash dump foes fight back - 02/20/05
Comment on this story
Send this story to a friend
Get Home Delivery
DETROIT -- Fish enthusiasts pleaded Monday for a reprieve for the
101-year-old Belle Isle Aquarium, arguing that cost of operating it is a
small price to pay for preserving the educational and cultural
Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick's administration has decided to close the
aquarium in March to save about $500,000 toward $94 million in cuts he
has to make to balance this year's budget.
"This is a legacy from our grandparents and we have a moral obligation
in supporting this institution for our grandchildren," said Kathleen
Alan, 45, of Ferndale, who helped start Friends of Belle Isle Aquarium
after the city announced the closing last month. She said the building,
designed by famed architect Albert Kahn, is the type of attraction the
city needs to showcase during next year's Super Bowl XL.
Councilmember JoAnn Watson said she'll introduce a resolution Wednesday
that would grant community and philanthropic groups one year to find
alternative funding, including an endowment, to sustain it. The City
Council could vote as early as Wednesday.
The debate highlights the challenge Detroit faces in cutting its budget:
For virtually every program in which cuts are proposed, there's a
constituency willing to fight for it. In this case, it's an aging
aquarium where attendance has fallen by 35 percent in the last four
If the City Council grants a stay, some city officials wondered how the
city will keep it running.
"While you deliberate, you spend the money the city doesn't have," said
Recreation Director Charles Beckham.
The zoo department says the city could save the $500,000 annually in
operating expenses, plus millions of dollars more that are needed to
keep the building safe and up to code. Currently, the aquarium has roof
problems and is not in compliance with the American with Disabilities
Zoo director Ron Kagan says he's willing to discuss keeping it open with
the help of private support.Kagan said he was encouraged by aquarium
support because attendance has fallen at both the zoo and aquarium in
recent years. Dozens attended the meeting.
Last year, 56,000 people visited Belle Isle Aquarium, a dramatic drop
from 86,000 in 2000.
At the Detroit Zoo in Royal Oak, attendance fell to 1 million from 1.4
million in 2000.
Some supporters accused the city of favoring the zoo over the aquarium,
but Kagan said the entire department has been affected by budget cuts.
"We place pride in that wonderful historic building and it's unfortunate
that people have misinterpreted our desire," he said.
Alan and nearly 2,000 people who signed an online petition in support of
keeping the aquarium open will have the challenge of raising $500,000 if
a year extension is granted. But members say that while they do not have
specific plans, they feel confident they can establish a nonprofit
organization to find the money.
"People will step up to the plate and they'll come through," said Thomas
A Wilson Jr., a board member of Friends of Belle Isle, another group
that supports the island park. "That aquarium will be saved."
Ruth Glancy, chairwoman and president of the Detroit Zoological Society,
which raises money for the Detroit Zoological Institute, said she hopes
money will be filtered through the society. When individuals and groups
donate to the society, they can designate which of the institute's three
operations -- the zoo, the aquarium, or the nature center -- receives
"The society already has an endowment," Glancy said. "I don't know why
you would start another organization. It's best to set up an
organization under the umbrella of the society and designate money for
During Monday's hearing, Alan and others questioned why the city felt a
need to close the aquarium when the city has gone through hard times
before. While the city is grappling with a $94 million deficit from last
fiscal year, the city operates on a $1.9 billion budget.
One supporter quoted former Mayor Coleman Young by saying, "You don't
give away the jewels for the price of polishing it."
Located on the southwest side of Belle Isle, the aquarium has 4,000
creatures, including two species -- the golden sawfin goodeid and the
pinstripe damba -- on the endangered list. So far, 70 creatures have
been relocated to the zoo, Kagan said.
Councilwoman Sharon McPhail suggested that the City Council should
consider filing an injunction to stop the transfer of all the creatures
and even floated the idea of suing the city to keep the aquarium open.
That idea is not new. When the city decided to close the zoo at Belle
Isle, City Council sued and lost.
Stephen Goodfellow of Highland Park says he takes his four-year-old son
there to learn about fish. Goodfellow created a Web site for Friends of
Belle Isle Aquarium called www.belleisleaquarium.com.
You can reach Judy Lin at (313) 222-2072 or firstname.lastname@example.org.